Fair ~ 58°F  
Login | Register
Thursday, October 27, 2016

Hagel should be rejected

Posted Wednesday, February 6, 2013, at 8:27 AM

He will probably be approved, but former Nebraska Republican Sen. Chuck Hagel should not, in our opinion, be confirmed as Leon Panetta's successor as Secretary of Defense.

Hagel's controversial opinions on Israel and Iran aside (those are, after all, merely policy differences), his appearance before the Senate Armed Services Committee could only be described, charitably, as clumsy.

Perhaps we've gotten spoiled. The outgoing Secretary of Defense, Leon Panetta, who was appointed by President Bush and asked to stay on by President Obama, has been one of the better secretaries in our memory. He has been forced to juggle two wars and a reduction in force at the same time, without any significant loss of national combat capability. His skills, and ability to think on his feet when meeting with foreign leaders (and more dangerously, members of Congress), have stood the United States well.

Hagel came with baggage, not the least of which were comments he made as a senator concerning Israel and Iran. In addition, many senators said that "he did not play well with others" as a senator and the animosity displayed during his confirmation hearings was a form of payback from senators whom he'd offended when he was on the other side of the table.

This does not bode well for his relations with Congress, which will be stressed by a further drawdown of forces to come (one in which only a good battler will be able to prevent Congress from leaving us back with a Carter-era hollow force).

Furthermore, he didn't seem capable of thinking on his feet, nor did he seem prepared for questions he should have known he was going to be asked.

It's not enough to be a noncommissioned Vietnam combat veteran. The Secretary of Defense has to be able to react quickly to changing circumstances, must be a top flight lobbyist and an excellent manager.

In general, presidents should get the people they want. But there's a reason the Senate is asked to "advise and consent" to the nominations, and this is one case where pulling the reins back may be a good idea.

-- Kelly Everitt

Showing comments in chronological order
[Show most recent comments first]

I am sure someone will correct me if I am wrong, but Bush appointed Gates to Secretary of Defense and he took office on Dec 18, 2006.

Obama asked Gates to be his Secretary of Defense also and he accepted and left office Jul 1, 2011.

Obama appointed Panetta, Bush did not appoint him.

Panetta took office 1 Jul 2011.

-- Posted by Eagle_eye on Wed, Feb 6, 2013, at 10:43 AM

Before being appointed as Defense Secretary, Mr. Panetta served as the CIA Director.

Eagle_eye's right re: appointments.

I like Mr. Panetta and I'm sorry to see him leave.

-- Posted by Dave Thompson on Wed, Feb 6, 2013, at 3:53 PM

I guess this blog can't or someone doesn't want to fix this sentence. It was changed yetersday and then changed again back to the wrong info.

Perhaps we've gotten spoiled. The outgoing Secretary of Defense, Leon Panetta, who was appointed by President Bush and asked to stay on by President Obama, has been one of the better secretaries in our memory

Bush "DID NOT APPOINT PANETTA" Obama appointed Panetta to replace Gates. Gates was the one asked to stay on by Obama. Panetta replaced Gates when he left.


-- Posted by Eagle_eye on Thu, Feb 7, 2013, at 2:56 PM


You mentioned McCains' questioning of Hagel, well after the circus that was Hilary Clinton's hearing maybe he started doing his job and I wish the rest would follow suit. They spend all their time thanking them for their service and never ask pertinent questions about the issue of the hearing.

And Hagel is a TOOL, I think your familiar with that word.

-- Posted by gmoney on Fri, Feb 8, 2013, at 1:11 PM

Respond to this blog

Posting a comment requires free registration:

Meanderings of the editor
Brian S. Orban
Recent posts
Blog RSS feed [Feed icon]
Comments RSS feed [Feed icon]
Hot topics
Issues missed during forum
(0 ~ 10:45 AM, Oct 26)

Let's pause, take a stand in fight vs. breast cancer
(0 ~ 10:55 AM, Oct 19)

If it's meant to be funny why am I not laughing?
(0 ~ 9:10 AM, Oct 12)

Turn it down or turn it off!
(1 ~ 9:14 AM, Oct 6)

Let's go, Mountain Home!
(3 ~ 2:06 PM, Oct 3)