Incumbents re-elected in record turnout

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

Elmore County voters turned out in record numbers Tuesday, both in the absolute number of voters and the percentage of registered voters who cast ballots, and voted to re-elect virtually every incumbent on the general election ballot.

Well over 8,000 voters cast ballots.

The hotly contested race for the Western Elmore County Recreation District saw incumbent Mollie Marsh turn back a challenge by Leanna Whitney by a narrow 1,841 to 1,436 margin.

Voters also overwhelmingly approved the creation of a pest (mosquito) abatement district to deal with the continuing threat of the West Nile Virus.

Perhaps the most serious challenge in all the other local races was in the three-way battle for sheriff, where 26-year incumbent Republican Rick Layher earned 4,296 votes (53.6 percent) to defeat Independent Gregg Berry, who received 2,411 votes, and Democrat Robin Ellis, who garnered 1,309 votes despite barely running at all.

In the race for the District 22 state senate seat, incumbent Republican Tim Corder easily turned back a challenge from G. Rustyn Casiano by a 5,747 to 2,049 margin.

The state representative Position B post for District 22 saw incumbent Republican Pete Nielsen easily defeat Rosemary Ardinger 5,128 to 2,622.

Rich Wills, the incumbent Republican who holds the Position A seat for District 22, was unopposed on the ballot and earned 6,680 votes.

Two positions were up for election for the Elmore County Board of Commissioners.

In the District 1 race, incumbent Republican Arlie Shaw won relection by a 4,868 to 2,852 margin over Democratic challenger Janet Langfitt.

For District 2, incumbent Republican Larry Rose easily handled the write-in challenge by independent Doug King, whom he'd defeated in the Republican primary in May, by a commanding 5,800 to 917 margin.

Democratic incumbent county prosecuting attorney Kristian Schindele, who was unopposed on the ballot, received 5,863 votes in local balloting Tuesday.

For state offices, Elmore County voters overwhelmingly favored Republican Lt. Gov. Jim Risch by a 5,031 to 2,466 margin over Democrat Larry LaRocco for the U.S. Senate seat being vacated by Sen. Larry Craig. Libertarian Kent Marmon earned 126 votes, independent candidate Rex Rammel earned 324 votes, and independent "Pro Life" (the former Marvin Richardson who had his name changed for the race) received 117 votes.

In the race for the Second Congressional District, incumbent Republican Mike Simpson crushed Democratic challenger Deborah Holmes by a 5,925 to 2,000 margin locally.

In the national race for president, Elmore County, like the rest of the state, overwhelmingly voted in favor of Republican John McCain over Democrat Barack Obama by a 5,571 to 2,523 margin locally. Also running on the presidential ballot was Constitution Party candidate Chuck Baldwin, who received 36 votes, Libertarian Bob Barr who received 33 votes, and Independent Ralph Nader who garnered 109 votes.

In balloting to affirm or reject the local magistrate judges, George Hicks received 6,344 votes to stay in office with 1,010 voters hoping to see him removed, while David Epis was reaffirmed by a 6,057 to 1,191 margin.

All totals are unofficial until the official canvass of ballots are held next week.

Comments
View 13 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • It is great to see that so many young adults are voting for their future. I'm glad to see that Sheriff Layher has been re-elected. Out of everyone running for Sheriff, Rick is the best for the job. I would like to Congratulate Rick on a job well done and we will be seeing you around for the next 4 years. Probably longer if you wish to seek re-election in '12.

    -- Posted by Weebro on Wed, Nov 5, 2008, at 1:48 AM
  • I had two great disappointments from this election. First was the lack of information available for the local candidates. As a young voter I rely heavily on the internet and TV for my information. The candidates for State Legislature, County Commissioner, Sheriff etc. were lucky if they had 1 interview available on the internet. I couldn't find most people on the internet and apparently the Boise TV stations don't know that Mountain Home or Elmore County exist! I never saw any information about our candidates coming from the big city. I might have voted for one of the challengers if I knew anything about them. The second was the lack of coverage about our elections by the Boise TV stations. I was unable to find out how the elections were going until this morning when I checked this website.

    -- Posted by Suds on Wed, Nov 5, 2008, at 8:35 AM
  • God bless America and the people of Elmore County for voting! And God help America continue to hold on to the basic freedoms that we hold dear. I pray for all of us to remain strong in our resolve to be a nation of the people, by the people and for the people!

    -- Posted by kimkovac on Wed, Nov 5, 2008, at 9:34 AM
  • I love being involved with such a large turn-out of voters! The results really mean something. It means, for me, a readjustment of my hopes in certain areas, but I really believe we all have to work together no matter what.

    -- Posted by senior lady on Wed, Nov 5, 2008, at 11:36 AM
  • Rick Layher won because the truth about him was suppressed. I can't imagine the people of Elmore County knowingly voting for a lying and corrupt incompetent. The job of being a law enforcement officer is tough and very stressful. In addition officers are often under appreciated and almost always underpaid. There have been a number of excellent officers in both the city and county over the years. Unfortunately there have also been some pinheads, sociopaths and hypocrites wearing badges in this community. The MHN should be going after them instead of protecting them. "Freedom of the press is a great thing but it must be used responsibly. Both sides of the story need to be told!"

    -- Posted by Perry Mason on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 11:26 AM
  • Perry Mason~~ I guess the people are on Rick's side because it shows through the votes that he won and took majority of the votes. He is a good person and does his job well. And calling him, "lying and corrupt incompetent" wow how low do you want to go as a person. I don't even respect your comment because people who talk bad about other people have too much time on their hands and must not have respect for their own self. I'm sorry but Rick won and it is what it is and he will keep on going doing the BEST job in this county.

    And for everyone else who has talked bad about Rick all I can say is only a few of you thought negative because it showed through the votes he is definetly a winner and the majority believes in him. Maybe you should reconsider what has been told to you or what you have heard, it's probably not true, you know Mountain Home is one of the biggest lying gossip towns around.

    -- Posted by truthful on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 12:57 PM
  • Perry Mason~~ I guess the people are on Rick's side because it shows through the votes that he won and took majority of the votes. He is a good person and does his job well. And calling him, "lying and corrupt incompetent" wow how low do you want to go as a person. I don't even respect your comment because people who talk bad about other people have too much time on their hands and must not have respect for their own self. I'm sorry but Rick won and it is what it is and he will keep on going doing the BEST job in this county.

    And for everyone else who has talked bad about Rick all I can say is only a few of you thought negative because it showed through the votes he is definetly a winner and the majority believes in him. Maybe you should reconsider what has been told to you or what you have heard, it's probably not true, you know Mountain Home is one of the biggest lying gossip towns around.

    -- Posted by truthful on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 12:58 PM
  • Perry Mason~~ I guess the people are on Rick's side because it shows through the votes that he won and took majority of the votes. He is a good person and does his job well. And calling him, "lying and corrupt incompetent" wow how low do you want to go as a person. I don't even respect your comment because people who talk bad about other people have too much time on their hands and must not have respect for their own self. I'm sorry but Rick won and it is what it is and he will keep on going doing the BEST job in this county.

    And for everyone else who has talked bad about Rick all I can say is only a few of you thought negative because it showed through the votes he is definetly a winner and the majority believes in him. Maybe you should reconsider what has been told to you or what you have heard, it's probably not true, you know Mountain Home is one of the biggest lying gossip towns around.

    -- Posted by truthful on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 12:59 PM
  • Perry Mason~~ I guess the people are on Rick's side because it shows through the votes that he won and took majority of the votes. He is a good person and does his job well. And calling him, "lying and corrupt incompetent" wow how low do you want to go as a person. I don't even respect your comment because people who talk bad about other people have too much time on their hands and must not have respect for their own self. I'm sorry but Rick won and it is what it is and he will keep on going doing the BEST job in this county.

    And for everyone else who has talked bad about Rick all I can say is only a few of you thought negative because it showed through the votes he is definetly a winner and the majority believes in him. Maybe you should reconsider what has been told to you or what you have heard, it's probably not true, you know Mountain Home is one of the biggest lying gossip towns around.

    -- Posted by truthful on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 1:01 PM
  • Anyone know what the percentage of voter turnout was?

    -- Posted by IdahoGirl on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 1:57 PM
  • Sure they do suds , but its only when it involves the militery ( no offense is meant to the militery ) someone dieing or killing someone or something blowing up / burning down.

    -- Posted by just1 on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 2:06 PM
  • Truthful,

    I certainly do not have too much time on my hands, I am spread very thin. But I hate seeing the people of Elmore County tricked out of having a decent man as their Sheriff. I myself stated that Mountain Home is a rumor mill on steroids and that there were things I had heard about Rick that I would not repeat because they seemed just too far fetched and I had been presented with no credible information to support these outrageous stories. The issues that I addressed in the questions I wanted Rick to be asked, involved actions of Rick's that I had heard about from one or more credible sources or in a few cases had even witnessed myself. It was fair to ask Rick these questions about his behavior since he was both a political candidate and a public official. The MHN however deleted my questions!

    There are numerous incidents out there involving Rick. I have heard about one in particular from several individuals in both law and law enforcement that I feel justifies everything I have said about him. Rick was testifying in court under oath about a felony case he had been involved in. The defendant in the case had allegedly been using marijuana during the crime. Rick should have administered a urine test to the man; results from such a test could have served to confirm or disprove the two conflicting stories in the case but he did not do so. When the defense attorney asked Rick why he had not done this; he testified that "it was too expensive". Further investigation by the defense discovered however that the State Crime Lab that analyzed urine samples for Elmore County did so for free! So Rick was lying and doing so under oath in a case involving a serious felony! The MHN printed nothing about the incident and Rick was never even investigated much less charged with perjury, his wife was the prosecutor at the time!

    -- Posted by Perry Mason on Thu, Nov 6, 2008, at 3:12 PM
  • Funny, for all the whining and complaining going on around town, ALL incumbents were reelected. Is that change. Speaking of change, how long before the incumbent county commisioners override planning and zoning again to keep jobs from going to colorado or Mexico...Were so lucky to have them. New jobs, Dairys Dumps and prisons.......ok. Have a good day.

    -- Posted by goatbeard on Fri, Nov 7, 2008, at 9:27 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: