If you can't take the heatPosted Wednesday, August 31, 2011, at 3:34 PM
I have taken some heat lately due to my opinions on certain issues. As the old saying goes, If you can't take the heat, then stay out of the kitchen.
Well, I'm still in the kitchen as you can tell. Most of us old timers know the origin of this phrase, for you younger ones, it was Harry S. Truman, and he is the subject of this blog.
I have a great deal of respect for this bespectacled, unassuming mid-westerner who was thrust into the national scene by the death of F.D.R. One of the things about this man that has earned my respect was the plaque on his desk that to this day should be a permanent fixture on the desk of The President Of The United States. THE BUCK STOPS HERE
That is a statement that says I take all responsibility for what I do with the power the people have given me. He is both vilified and revered for his actions during the Korean Conflict with regards to General Douglas MacArthur.
The question was what to do with an enormously popular general who openly questioned your decisions as Commander In Chief. I am of course referring to the question of invading China.
Now I have never really studied this episode in American history, but it does fascinate me.
I think I understand where the general was coming from. The desire for victory and the hatred of communism. After all, he was a military man, a General.
As far as Truman, I think I might understand where he came from. The reality was that invading China was a losing proposition. We would have been out manned, out gunned, and they had a very powerful ally. Conventional warfare was out. I'm sure that there those who argued the Nuclear Option. Thankfully they never had their way. If they had, none of us most likely would be here today.
So my question today is, Is it ever right for a person in the military to question, openly, a direct order from the commander in chief? What if that person questioned the commander in chief to their peers or subordinates? What if that same person openly defied the commander in chief and refused orders? I'm sure some of you might think I have gone off the deep end for bringing up this subject in a military community, but really, where better? Who better to answer these questions?
As always, all opinions are welcome. Please try and stay on topic, and do as I'm sure your mothers taught you, keep a civil tongue.
Showing comments in chronological order
[Show most recent comments first]
A View From The Independent Side
- Blog RSS feed
- Comments RSS feed
- Send email to Roy Pratt
I'm an almost 61 year old transplant from California 6 1/2 years ago. I work in road construction, those dastardly flaggers. My family roots go back to New England farms, not the big city. The last town I lived in when in California grew from 16K to 40K in 10 years, and that was enough to drive me out. I don't engage in or tolerate name calling. Name calling reduces an adult discussion to grade school play yard level. I have never served in the military, but have family members who have, dating back to WW1. I am neither a Democrat nor a Republican. I am neither extremely Liberal or Conservative. I am raising my 16 year old grandson, not what I expected at this age, and dealing with those issues as well as my health and near retirement which are 2 things I intend to talk about. I decided to try my hand at this thanks to the warm welcome I have received on Mike's blog. When I take a position, I will defend it until I am shown that I am mistaken, and when that happens, I apologize. There are other things about me that will come out over time I'm sure.
Hot topicsThis is a Man and a Company that GETS IT! A celebration of what America should be about!
(43 ~ 7:25 AM, Mar 2)
What the next World War might look like
Ever wonder what the air could look like without the EPA?
News flash from Fox News
MARRIAGE IS CIVIL RIGHT ( RITE) AS WELL AS RELIGIOUS SACRAMENT